13 April 2009

The Death of Simile: The Future of Poetry?

the trouble with poetry is
that it encourages the writing of more poetry,
more guppies crowding the fish tank,
more baby rabbits
hopping out of their mothers into the dewy grass.

And how will it ever end?
unless the day finally arrives
when we have compared everything in the world
to everything else in the world,

and there is nothing left to do
but quietly close our notebooks
and sit with our hands folded on our desks.

from "The Trouble with Poetry" by Billy Collins

I am sitting at my desk, wearing a pink cardigan over my pajamas. It is still dark. It is not yet morning. I hear the pied piper ice cream truck, already sounding its chimes. I hear church bells from the nearby Basilica. I hear garbage trucks. I look at my plants and notice my rumpled bed.

There is nothing more to compare these moments to, dark and warm here in my room, and I wonder what will happen when we run out of oil, food, materials for recycled messenger bags, and similes, and when everything just stops.

Perhaps, in a way, this has already happened. Some have already taken a choose-your-own-adventure approach to the creation of images. If there was ever a harbinger of progressive poetics, it would, of course, be Soulja Boy.

'We on the phone like...'
The profundity of this and similar lyrics compels me to wonder if perhaps merely the first half of any simile is necessary, followed by beats, mumbles, a melodic representation of a ten-digit telephone number, or a string of da-da-da-das. Because for some reason, when we hear "We takin' pics like..." we know exactly what he means.

Proposed Solutions
Now, if the solution to the so-called "oil crisis" is a so-called "lifestyle change," how can we remedy this comparison dilemma?

'You could be my Bonnie, I could be your Clyde'
One idea is to start using metaphors exclusively, thus doing away with "like" and "as" altogether. Unfortunately, this concept is like switching to corn ethanol: unsustainable and pointless.

'Everything about you I like it, I love it'
Or, we could just stop describing things altogether. We could stop needing images. We could stop needing to know about the steaming coffee, how quiet the night was, how the curtains swung, the taste of cinnamon tea on her mouth, his whistling, the smell of spring, the morning light. If we could stop wondering about these things we could go on without poetry at all.

'No tellin' what I'm gon' do; baby I'm about to show you'
Maybe, in the future, our minds will be born already full of images. "My love is like," you hear, and in an instant your brain selects an image from its catalog of comparisons. Jamie Foxx, however, must have had an English teacher like mine, always harping to "show, don't tell" in our compositions, and this--this gives me hope for the future of poetry.

7 comments:

JacobG said...

Lolol, why are you drunk on vodka at 6am?

And why did my rss feed only now notify me of this post yet blogspot says it is from April 13 of the year 2009? Did you blog this from the past? Should this be tagged as time travel?

moonrose said...

clearly 'vodka' is a lyrical reference. and yes i wrote it from the past. again.

McKinley Ann said...

Could we also just take a leap and say definitively that something is, and not just like, or similar to, something else? Sort of like (ha!) the Bonnie and Clyde example (metaphor), but accepting that there may exist something beyond a metaphor-- a truth-- in the mind of those who conceive of it. And true or not for the listener or reading literally speaking, no one can judge whether for someone else something is merely a metaphor or indeed a truth, because in his mind and his person, for Shakespeare all the world was a stage, and for me, chaos is my most beloved companion.

"The metaphor reminds us that the universe is full of cousins."

J.D. Casnig

If so, the metaphor points to a truth, that all things are interconnected and cannot simply be compared, but constantly identified with one another. And that would support that in some moment all things will end because they cannot exist without each other, and we cannot exist without them.

And I was going to use Howl as an example but then anyone who read this would renounce my above ramblings because they would think that I was on drugs.

Now I shall sit with my hands folded and stare at the wall.

Anonymous said...

i always tell. never show

moonrose said...

Dear Anonymous,

That's not what she said!

JacobG said...

As expected, Star Trek has already explored the case of using metaphors as truth.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukMNfTnI5M8

Here is the pivotal moment where Captain Picard finally succeeds in rudimentary interaction with one of a species that communicates solely through the use of metaphors. So when the alien says "Darmok and Jelad at Tenagra" he is not saying Picard and himself are like Darmok and Jelad (characters of the alien's mythos) but that they are and that is good enough to describe the situation. Their entire culture is built on communication through metaphors as truth and reality.

Anonymous said...

nice read. I would love to follow you on twitter.